Should Redmon Crematorium Plan Go up in Smoke? (POLL)
Critics of Redmon's proposal to add a crematorium say it presents potentially serious health risks, while proponents say they've been a good neighbor and will use it responsibly.
Redmon Funeral Home wants to add a crematorium to its services, and the thought of living next to or near it has several Stow residents up in arms.
At Monday's city council meeting, several people spoke out against the addition of a crematorium, saying it poses potential health risks to children, the elderly and pregnant women. Others said Redmon is a good neighbor and will handle the service with care and caution.
City council will make the final decision at Thursday's 7 p.m. council meeting.
We want to know what you think. Tell us in the comments below and take our poll.
Here's what people on Stow Patch's Facebook page and other articles are saying:
Geoffrey Besso I support it. Look at the data. Interview people in communities that have it, they probably don't even know they have one. I'd love to see some reporting on the matter, to help inform people.
Jessica Dickey I grew up by a crematory and lived next to one for 6 years. People threw a huge fit in Kent when they were trying to put one in. Once it went in, I never heard anything about it again. It never bothered me when I lived next door, no smell or tons of smoke. You only knew it was happening if you stared at the roof and watched for it.
Heather Beale DeSessa I don't see an issue. Do the residents think the bodies will be in a backyard bonfire behind Redmon? Come on, there are boatloads of regulations they have to abide by. I hope Redmon gets approved.
Larry Kinnan I encourage everyone to make their views known to the Mayor and Coucil members before or during Thursday's meeting regarding this issue. It is clear that there is significant unknowns regarding the impact of allowing the addition of cremation services to the surrounding area and is adjacent to a residential area. Contrary to Ms. Hanson's statement that residents want 100% assurance of safety, it is clear that there are still too many unknowns to justify the change being requested at this time.
Ed Fisher My biggest concern here is the almost instant opposition to this project. My online research reveals that crematoriums are becoming commonplace in this country, and the technology connected to these facilities render them relatively harmless to the environment. Now, that being said, I don't particularly care if the crematory is built or not. But I am worried that we, as a city, must be completely sure of what's on the table before the hysteria sets in. Business interests in any city must get a fair shake, based on facts alone. The notion (implied) of human body particulates and mercury permeating the skies over Stow are not based in fact. If this business opportunity is to be denied, it must be done without the doomsday narratives and "sky is falling" rhetoric.
JenniGS
8:27 am on Wednesday, December 12, 2012
The Redmons have been one of the most respected families in our community for many, many years. They have comforted the majority of us by making an already difficult time a little less stressful, they have instituted a greif center, they are the ones we turn to when we experience the death of a loved one because of their experience and kind compassion. Do we really think this family would put any of us in jeopardy? I have every confidence that they will take all necessary steps to keep our community safe. Cremation is a service, so why not trust the family who has been serving us for so many years? They have my support!
JIM STARKEY
10:52 am on Wednesday, December 12, 2012
There is no issue other thanemotional stuff to prevent the redmon's funeral home having a crematory.. There are other funeral homes in Akron area andno problems have ever been caused or questioned. Support a great name Redmon and approve this thing. The burger kings and macdonalds create more smoke and pollution!!!!
Janine Daymon
4:20 pm on Wednesday, December 12, 2012
I agree with JenniGS. John and I have known the Redmon Family most of our lives. From being classmates of Kevin and Keith to depending on them to be there for us when we lost a loved one. I cannot say enough about the respect we have for the entire family. They have always been dignified, compassionate and a huge part of the Stow Community in a positive way. I believe people need to be open minded and know that the Redmon's would never do something that would put anyone's health or well being at risk. Think of it as them providing another needed service to our families in our time of need. I hope everyone will support the Redmons.
Jack Kelly
6:51 am on Thursday, December 13, 2012
"It is clear that there is significant unknowns regarding the impact of allowing the addition of cremation services to the surrounding area and is adjacent to a residential area."
Wrong. Start citing substantiated and consistent data or be quiet already.
Geoffrey Watson
8:14 am on Thursday, December 13, 2012
I really see no problem with having one. There is one at the intersection of Gilchrist Rd and SR-91 in Akron,OH. I worked around the area for months and never even knew they were there until someone pointed it out to me.
Having one in a residential area might be a different story. They don't seem to smell but I am not sure I would want one by my house. It's just the idea.
JIM STARKEY
3:40 pm on Thursday, December 13, 2012
Yes, Geoff, There has been one at 91 and Gilchrist Rd. for years. I am not sure how long, but I worked until I retired in that area and never knew until this past year that there was a crematory there. I also agree with Jack. Start presenting substantiated data , or just sit down and be quiet. This hysteria kind of thing never ever helps either side.
Enrico Caruso
11:27 am on Friday, December 14, 2012
Stow City Legislation 2012-165 that would allow crematoria should be defeated. It is a threat to human health. You cannot see the harmful mercury vapor emission that sprews from the exhaust stack. The mercury vapor results from mercury containing dental amalgem fillings in cadavers. 8% of world mercury demand is for dental use. Mercury poisoning affects the brain, neurological system, kidneys, lungs, etc. There have been numerous scientific studies presented in the world showing the dangers of crematoria emissions. The EU countries recognized the dangers in 2003 at the OSPAR convention, and the UK followed with a 2005 law AQ1(05) requiring all crematories in the country to be retrofitted with mercury vapor abatement technology in the hope of reducing such emission by only 50% of the 2003 level. The USEPA has been negligent is giving the cremator industry a pass (by declaring that a dead human is not solid waste), while at the same time highly regulating the incineration of medical waste which contains human limbs and organs, and other solid waste incinerators. This matter has nothing to do with the familes that owns either of the two Stow funeral homes, because they would have no direct control over the mercury, or any other emissions, issuing from the 33 3/8" diameter exhaust stack. There was a time when the tobacco industry denied the health effects of their product, and the gasoline and paint industries did likewise with lead, and hardware was coated with cadmium. We learn